Statutory or informal lease extension: which is better?
The statutory route, under section 42 of the Leasehold Reform, Housing and Urban Development Act 1993, gives you a right the freeholder cannot refuse: a new lease on the same terms, for a term extended by 990 years under the 2024 Act (not yet in force as at 19 September 2026; no commencement date announced), at a peppercorn ground rent, for a premium set by a statutory formula with the First-tier Tribunal (Property Chamber) as the backstop. The informal route is whatever the freeholder is willing to offer, on whatever terms, at whatever price, and it can be withdrawn at any point before completion.
Informal deals are sometimes quicker and occasionally cheaper, particularly where the freeholder is a residents' company and the flat owners are effectively extending their own leases. They are also where leaseholders get caught: fewer years, a ground rent that survives or escalates, and new terms slipped into the deed. Where a voluntary extension is granted, the Leasehold Reform (Ground Rent) Act 2022 does reach it, because an extension by deed of variation operates as a surrender and regrant and sections 1(4) and 1(5) treat that as the grant of a lease. What the Act then does is split the term: under section 6, the part matching what was left of the old lease is an excepted period on which the old rent can continue, and the additional years are a regulated period on which the rent is limited to a peppercorn (checked 20 September 2026). So the old rent is not swept away, and only the new years are at a peppercorn. We compare every offer with the statutory figure before you respond.
| Statutory (section 42) | Informal agreement | |
|---|---|---|
| Years added | 990 years under the 2024 Act (not yet in force as at 19 September 2026; no commencement date announced); 90 years before it | Whatever is offered, often less |
| Ground rent | Reduced to a peppercorn for the whole term | May be kept, or increased, on the existing term |
| Premium | Statutory formula, Tribunal as backstop | Whatever is negotiated, no backstop |
| Freeholder can refuse | No, if you qualify | Yes, and can withdraw at any point |
| Freeholder's costs | Payable by you: section 60 of the 1993 Act still stands. Section 39 of the Leasehold and Freehold Reform Act 2024 would remove it, but it was not in force at Royal Assent and no commencement order has been made (checked 20 September 2026) | Whatever is agreed |
| Time | Six to twelve months | Two to four months, if the freeholder engages |
| Other terms | Same as the existing lease, with limited modernisation | Open to renegotiation, and new terms can be added |
What has the Leasehold and Freehold Reform Act 2024 changed?
The Act rewrites the lease extension rules in the leaseholder's favour, but its provisions commence in stages by regulations, so what applies on the day you serve notice depends on which sections are in force. Already in force: the two-year ownership requirement has been abolished for flats and houses, so a new owner can serve notice at once (section 27 of the Leasehold and Freehold Reform Act 2024, in force 31 January 2025, checked 19 September 2026). Awaiting or recently commenced (not yet in force as at 19 September 2026; no commencement date announced): the extended term becomes 990 years for flats and houses; marriage value and hope value are removed from the premium; the capitalisation and deferment rates are prescribed rather than argued over; ground rent above a set level is capped in the valuation; and leaseholders stop paying the freeholder's non-litigation costs in most cases.
The practical effect, once fully in force, is a lower premium for most short leases, a much longer term, and a cheaper process. The practical question for anyone with a lease near 80 years is whether to serve now under the current valuation rules or wait for the reforms. That depends on your lease, your ground rent and how soon you need to sell or remortgage, and we set the two figures out in writing rather than guessing. The Act's commencement regulations, published on legislation.gov.uk, are the record of what is in force on any given date.
Do I need my lender's consent to extend my lease?
Yes, if there is a mortgage. The new lease replaces the old one, and the lender's charge must be carried across to it, either by the lender consenting to the surrender and regrant or by a deed of substituted security (each lender sets its own rule in part 2 of its UK Finance handbook entry). Lenders welcome a longer lease and consent is rarely refused, but it must be obtained before completion and the lender may charge an administration fee. If the premium is being funded by a remortgage, the two complete on the same day and the new lender takes its charge over the new lease.
A statutory extension is not a purchase of land for Stamp Duty Land Tax purposes in the way a sale is, but a premium paid for a new lease is chargeable consideration, so a Stamp Duty Land Tax return, or a Land Transaction Tax return to the Welsh Revenue Authority in Wales, may be required and tax may be due where the premium exceeds the threshold. A statutory extension operates as a surrender and regrant, and paragraph 16 of Schedule 17A to the Finance Act 2003 stops the surrender being treated as consideration for the new lease, or the new lease as consideration for the surrender, so it is the premium that is taxed and not the value of what is given up. Wales has the same rule at paragraph 17 of Schedule 6 to the Land Transaction Tax and Anti-avoidance of Devolved Taxes (Wales) Act 2017 (checked 20 September 2026). We check the position before completion.